THE NEWS
Semifinals (or if you’re from my generation, regionals) are back!
In case you missed some of the chatter in the CrossFit games community last week, there were a lot of penalties and scores affected over the quarterfinals weekend.
Now this is important because quarterfinals is the crucible you have to go through to get to semi finals which is an in person CrossFit games event that can qualify you for the CrossFit games.
Having been through these qualifying rounds myself, I know how stressful it can be to create videos that meet the movement and viewing standards. it takes a lot of time to set up the competition floor and find the correct angle for a camera to show that you were meeting the standard.
There were always problems from judges, reviewers and athletes trying to skirt standards followed by attempts to solve those problems from about 2012 on.
Having been through those years the entire community should know that if you plan to qualify for the CrossFit games or any of the in person events prior to it, your videos should be perfect in order to not leave the outcome up to judges or reviewers.
If that means moving a little bit slower to make sure that you get credit for a rep then that’s what you need to do.
The penalties you receive for “no reps” on a video review are far greater than the time it would take to just make sure that you do clean reps and maybe move just a bit more slowly and deliberately on one movement.
The biggest issue this year was with the dumbbell box step up movement. For both dumbbell box step ups and regular box jumps, It can be difficult to remember as an athlete to get your head, shoulder hip and knee all in line and fully extended.
For instance, I can extend my knee fully open my hip completely, but still have my shoulders out over my toes with my head dropped forward. This will make it look like I have not stood all the way up to meet the standard and in reality I have not if the head and shoulders are what the standard requires.
Now the problem I have with some of the athletes complaints is that it wasn’t just words that were written in order to guide them to meet the standard.
There are clear pictures that show exactly how each rep should finish at the top of the box, and exactly how they shouldn’t look and it’s the athletes responsibility to achieve the standard.
That being said, I think there’s several movements that are absolutely horrible for workouts that require video submission from moving onto a next round.
The dumbbell box step up as well as the box jump are for sure two of those movements when this problem could easily be resolved by simply requiring a dumbbell box step over or a box jump over.
There is no ambiguity in a video if somebody has stepped all the way over a box or has jumped all the way over the box. For all online qualifiers, movements should be kept as simple as possible for both the judges, the athletes and the review team.
No matter what the fittest will always rise to the top, for the most part. The other gaping hole in this qualification process is that while some videos get reviewed, receive massive penalties, and drop down the leaderboard, others don’t get reviewed at all, namely all those people you just dropped beneath.
So how do we know all those video’s aren’t bad as well? We don’t.
One of the better ways I have seen to solve this problem is two leaderboards. One for those who plan to submit video’s and be held to the highest standard and another for those who just want their name on the leaderboard. Does this completely solve the problem? No but it’s a start.
The only consistent thing that has occurred these past few years with the Games is change. And it appears we will be seeing more of that for the online qualiifers next year.
You can watch all the action unfold for the semifinals weekends over at CrossFitGames.com